Step 3 of 5 · Negotiate · 6 min read
How to Negotiate a Car Price by Email: Templates for Every Step
The multi-dealer email method for negotiating a car price, with copy-paste templates for the first email, follow-up, counteroffer, and acceptance.
Listen to this guide8 min
The short version
- Email several dealers about specific cars and ask each for an itemized out-the-door price. Let the quotes compete.
- You negotiate from home, in writing, on one number. No one can rush you.
- Be honest: say you are asking several dealers, and do not invent offers you do not have.
- One round of counteroffers is usually enough. Then accept the best quote in writing and book a time to sign.
- Bring the email thread to the dealership and check the contract against it.
In this guide
The simplest way to negotiate a car price is to not do it face to face. Email several dealers that have the car you want, ask each for the same thing, an itemized out-the-door price, and compare the answers. The dealers compete with each other, and you never have to haggle across a desk.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) says much the same: settle the details before you visit, because your bargaining power is greatest before you go to the lot.
This works especially well for new cars, because the same model and trim is an identical product at every dealer. For used cars, you compare similar cars instead of identical ones.
Before you send anything
- Decide the exact car. Year, model, trim, drivetrain, must-have options. List colors you would accept; more colors means more dealers.
- Test drive first. Email negotiation is for price, not for deciding whether you like the car. See how to test drive a car.
- Get preapproved. So financing is not a variable. See car loan preapproval.
- Find the cars. Search live listings and pick four to six dealers with a matching car in stock. Note each VIN and stock number, and how long each has been listed. See how to read a dealer listing.
- Know the market. From those listings you already have a sense of the going advertised price. See MSRP, invoice, and market price.
Address the email to the internet sales department if the dealer lists one. Otherwise use the listing's contact form.
Email 1: the request
Send this to each dealer, with that dealer's specific car filled in.
Subject: Out-the-door price request: [Year Make Model Trim], stock #[number]
Hello,
I'm buying a [Year Make Model Trim] in the next [7 to 10 days] and I'm contacting a few dealers in the area. I'm interested in the one you have listed, VIN [VIN], stock #[number].
Could you send me your best itemized out-the-door price for this car? Please show:
- Selling price
- Manufacturer incentives applied (I qualify for: [list, or "standard customer offers only"])
- Any dealer-installed accessories or add-ons, with prices, and whether they can be removed
- Each dealer fee
- Estimated tax, title, and registration for ZIP [ZIP], registering in [state]
- Total out-the-door price
I have financing arranged and I'm open to yours if the rate is better. [No trade-in. / I have a trade-in that I'll handle separately once we agree on a price.]
I'll go with the best total, and I'm ready to come in and sign once we agree in writing. Email is the best way to reach me.
Thank you, [Name]
What comes back
Expect a mix:
- An itemized quote. Thank them. Add it to your comparison.
- A price without the breakdown. Use follow-up A.
- "When can you come in?" or "Call me." Use follow-up B.
- Nothing. Wait two business days, then send follow-up C once.
Put each quote in a table:
| Dealer | Selling price | Add-ons | Dealer fees | Tax, title, reg | Out-the-door | Conditions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | ||||||
| B | ||||||
| C |
The "conditions" column matters. A quote that requires dealer financing or includes a rebate you do not qualify for is not equal to one that does not. See out-the-door price for what each line should contain, and dealer fees explained for which fees are normal.
Email 2: follow-ups
A. Price without a breakdown
Thanks for the quick reply. To compare fairly, could you send it itemized: selling price, any add-ons, each fee, and estimated tax and registration, with the out-the-door total? I appreciate it.
B. "Come in" or "call me"
Thanks. I'm glad to come in to sign once we've agreed on the out-the-door price in writing. I'm deciding between a few dealers this week based on that number. If you can send the itemized quote, you're in the running.
C. No reply
Following up on my note below about stock #[number]. I'm making a decision by [day]. If you'd like to quote it, I'd be glad to include you.
If a dealer will not put a number in writing after that, leave them out. Some stores prefer to work in person, and you only need two or three good quotes.
Email 3: the counter
Once you have the quotes, go back to the dealers who are not lowest and give them one chance to improve. Be truthful about the number you hold.
Thank you for the quote on stock #[number] at $[their OTD] out the door.
I have a written quote on a comparable [Model Trim] at $[best OTD] out the door. I'd like to buy from you [because you're closer / because of the color]. If you can get to $[target] out the door, with no add-ons beyond what's itemized, I'll come in [day] and sign.
If that isn't workable, I understand, and thanks for your time.
Notes:
- Do not invent a quote. Dealers know the market, and a number that could not be real ends the conversation. You may be asked to forward the competing quote. Whether you share it is your choice; sharing the figures without the other dealer's name is a reasonable middle.
- Set a target that is plausible. A little under your best quote is plausible. Thousands under is not.
- Go back to the lowest dealer too, differently: "You're the best quote so far. Is this your best price, or is there any room? I'm deciding tomorrow."
- One round is usually enough.
If you are comparing used cars, adjust for differences in mileage, condition, and history before you compare totals, and make any agreement subject to a pre-purchase inspection.
Email 4: the acceptance
When you have a number you are happy with, confirm every term in one message and ask for a reply.
Thank you. I accept. To confirm what we've agreed:
- Vehicle: [Year Make Model Trim, color], VIN [VIN], stock #[number]
- Out-the-door price: $[amount], per your itemized quote of [date], attached
- No additional products, accessories, or fees beyond that quote
- Financing: [my own lender / open to yours if you can beat X.XX% APR for XX months]
- [Trade-in: none / to be appraised separately]
I can come in [day] at [time]. Could you confirm these terms and that the car will be there and ready? Also, please let me know what to bring.
[Name]
Wait for the reply before you go. If a deposit is requested to hold the car, ask in writing whether it is refundable and how it is applied.
Then send a short note to the other dealers: "I've decided to buy elsewhere. Thank you for the quote." It is fair to them, and they will stop following up.
At the dealership
Bring the whole thread, printed or on your phone.
- Check the VIN on the car against the email.
- Check the numbers on the buyer's order and the contract against the itemized quote. Tax and registration may differ slightly from the estimate. Nothing else should.
- Expect the finance office to offer optional products. You can decline. See the finance office: what to expect.
- If a number has changed, point to the email: "We agreed to this in writing. Can we correct it?" Most of the time it gets corrected. If it does not, the FTC's advice is to be ready to walk away, and when to walk away from a car deal explains how.
Common questions
What if the car is scarce? There is less to negotiate, but the method still shows who is selling at sticker. See dealer markups and market adjustments.
What about my trade-in? Keep it out of the price emails. Get separate written offers for it. See trade-in value: how to get more.
What if I would prefer not to do this at all? Collecting and comparing quotes is exactly what our concierge does on your behalf.
Read next · Step 3: Negotiate
Dealer Fees Explained: Which Are Real and Which Are Negotiable
6 min