Step 1 of 5 · Decide · 5 min read
The Best Time to Buy a Car: What Timing Changes and What Is Myth
What really moves a car deal: sales targets, model-year changeover, and how long a car has sat. Plus the timing myths you can safely ignore.
Listen to this guide7 min
The short version
- Timing helps at the margin. Preparation, comparison quotes, and flexibility on the exact car matter more.
- Three timing effects are real: sales targets at period ends, outgoing model years, and cars that have sat on the lot.
- How long a specific car has been listed is more useful than the calendar, and you can look it up.
- The best time to buy is when you are ready and not in a hurry. Needing a car by Saturday costs more than any bad month.
In this guide
Timing matters less than most articles suggest. A prepared buyer on an ordinary Tuesday in the middle of the month usually does better than an unprepared one on the last day of the year. But a few timing effects are real, and they are worth understanding so you can use them when it costs you nothing.
We are not going to give you "you save X% in December" figures. Those numbers vary by year, brand, and model, and averages hide more than they show. Here is how the mechanisms work instead, so you can check them against live prices yourself.
What timing really changes
1. Sales targets at the end of a period
Dealerships and salespeople are commonly paid in part on volume. Manufacturers often set sales objectives for dealers over a month or a quarter, with bonus money for reaching them. Salespeople frequently have monthly unit targets of their own.
When a store is one or two cars short of a target with a few days left, the bonus for hitting it can be worth more to the dealer than the profit on a single car. In that situation a dealer may accept a thinner deal than usual.
The limits:
- You cannot see a dealer's targets or how close they are. A store that already hit its number, or has no hope of hitting it, has no extra reason to stretch.
- Not every brand or store is run this way.
- Period ends are busy. You may get less attention and feel more rushed.
How to use it: do your comparison shopping by email in the last week of the month and be ready to sign on a weekday before the final day. You get whatever benefit exists without the Saturday crowd.
2. Model-year changeover
When next year's model arrives, the outgoing year becomes the thing the dealer and the manufacturer want gone. Manufacturers often raise incentives on the outgoing year, and dealers discount more willingly because each month it sits it looks older.
Changeover does not happen on a fixed date. New model years arrive at different times across brands and models, commonly from late summer onward but sometimes much earlier or later. You find out by looking: when listings for the new model year start appearing alongside the old one, the changeover has begun.
The trade-offs:
- Selection shrinks. The remaining cars may not be in your color or trim.
- The outgoing car is a model year older the day you buy it, which affects resale value later. If you keep cars a long time, this hardly matters. If you trade every three years, it matters more. See depreciation explained.
- If the new year is a redesign, the old one is an older design. If it is a carryover with no real changes, the old one is the same car for less.
3. How long this particular car has been for sale
This is the most useful timing signal, and it has nothing to do with the calendar.
Dealers generally finance their inventory, so each car on the lot costs money every day it sits. A car listed for three days and a car listed for ninety are different negotiations, even if they are identical. On the older listing the dealer has usually cut the price already and has more reason to cut again.
You do not need to guess. Every listing on The Motor Standard shows when we first saw the car and each price change since. A car with a long history and a couple of price drops is a car the dealer wants to move. How to read a dealer listing explains how to interpret this.
One caution: ask why a car has sat. Sometimes it is an odd color or option mix, which is fine if you like it. On a used car, it may be something an inspection would find.
4. Incentive cycles
Manufacturer rebates and special financing rates are usually set for a period, often a month, and then renewed, changed, or dropped. A good offer this month may not exist next month, and a better one may appear.
So check the manufacturer's site for current offers in your ZIP code before you negotiate, and note the expiry date. If an offer you want ends soon, that is a legitimate reason to finish your purchase before it does. See rebates and incentives explained.
What is mostly myth
"Holiday sales events have the best prices." Holiday weekends bring heavy advertising. Sometimes the manufacturer incentives behind the ads are better than the weeks around them, and sometimes they are the same offers with a banner on top. Compare the actual out-the-door price, not the event name. The FTC notes that advertised prices and offers can come with restrictions and conditions in the fine print, so read them.
"Go on a rainy day" or "go on a Monday." A quiet showroom gets you more of a salesperson's time, which is pleasant. There is no reliable reason it changes the price. If you negotiate by email, the weather at the dealership is irrelevant.
"Go at the end of the day so they are tired and want to go home." You will be tired too, and a rushed signing is where mistakes get through. The paperwork deserves a clear head. See the finance office: what to expect.
"There is a best month for everyone." The year-end period combines several real effects: month, quarter, and year targets, plus outgoing model years. It can be a good time. It can also be a period of thin selection, and in years when inventory is tight the discounts may be small. No month is reliably best for every model.
"Wait, prices are about to drop." Nobody knows this reliably. If you need a car, the cost of waiting (repairs on the old one, rentals, stress) is real, while the predicted drop is a guess.
Timing that matters more than the calendar
Your own readiness. The worst time to buy is when you have to. A dead car and a Monday deadline remove your ability to walk away, and that ability is most of your bargaining position. If your current car is showing its age, start shopping before it fails.
Your financing. Get a preapproval first. It is valid for a limited time, typically stated in the approval, so line it up when you are within a few weeks of buying.
Ordering versus buying from stock. If the exact car you want is not on any lot, a factory order avoids paying for options you do not want, but it takes time and the incentives that apply are usually set by rules you should confirm in writing. See ordering a new car from the factory.
A simple plan
- Start two to four weeks before you want to be driving the new car.
- Find three to five cars that fit, across several dealers. Note how long each has been listed and its price history.
- Check current manufacturer offers and their end dates.
- In the last week or so of the month, email for out-the-door quotes using the email method.
- Sign on a weekday when you are rested and have an hour to read the paperwork.
If the end of the month does not line up with your life, do not force it. Comparison quotes on a car that has been listed a while will do more for you than the date.
Read next · Step 1: Decide
How to Buy a Car, Step by Step: From Budget to Driving Home
6 min