Skip to content
The Motor Standard

Step 4 of 5 · Sign · 7 min read

Extended Warranties and Service Contracts: How to Decide

What a vehicle service contract is, how manufacturer-backed and third-party plans differ, the questions to ask, and why you rarely need to decide today.

Listen to this guide10 min

The short version

  • An extended warranty is a service contract: an optional product sold separately, not a warranty under federal law.
  • You generally cannot be required to buy one to get a loan, according to the CFPB.
  • You usually do not have to decide in the finance office. Plans can typically be bought later, while the factory warranty is still running.
  • Judge a contract by who backs it, what it excludes, where repairs can be done and how claims are paid.
  • The price is negotiable, and contracts can usually be cancelled. Refund terms depend on the contract and your state.
In this guide
  1. Three things to know before the pitch
  2. Who is behind the contract
  3. How to read the contract
  4. Price
  5. Is it worth it for you?
  6. Cancelling and refunds
  7. Scam calls and mailers
  8. If a claim is denied

An "extended warranty" is a vehicle service contract: you pay a fee, and the contract promises to pay for certain repairs for a set time or mileage. It is optional, it is sold separately from the car, and it is one of the main products offered in the dealership's finance office. The FTC says it plainly: "An auto service contract or extended warranty is not a warranty as defined by federal law, because you buy it separately."

Some people get real value from one. The FTC also cautions that you might pay more for a service contract than you get back in benefits. The way to decide is to slow down, read the actual contract, and compare it with the coverage you already have.

Three things to know before the pitch

  1. It is optional. The CFPB says that generally you cannot be required to buy an extended warranty to get an auto loan. If someone says it is required, ask them to show you where the contract says so, or check with the lender directly.
  2. You probably already have coverage. A new car comes with a factory warranty, and a service contract that overlaps it adds little during those years. The FTC advises comparing the contract's start and end dates with the factory warranty. New car warranty explained shows what you already have.
  3. You can usually buy later. Manufacturer-backed plans can generally be purchased any time before the factory warranty expires, sometimes with rules about age and mileage, and third-party plans are sold for cars of many ages. Prices and eligibility can change as the car ages, so ask for the cutoff. The point is that the deadline is rarely today.

A line for the finance office: "I am not going to decide on a service contract today. Please give me a copy of the actual contract and the price in writing so I can read it at home."

Who is behind the contract

Three parties can be involved, and they are not always the same company: the seller (often the dealer), the administrator who approves and pays claims, and the insurer or obligor who backs the promise financially. The FTC notes that dealer-sold contracts are often handled by administrators who decide whether claims are paid.

Manufacturer-backed planThird-party plan
Backed byThe automaker or its affiliateAn independent company, often with an insurer behind it
Where repairs are doneGenerally any franchised dealer for the brandVaries: a network of shops, any licensed shop, or only the selling dealer
PartsTypically original manufacturer partsMay allow used or aftermarket parts
How claims are paidUsually directly to the dealerDirect payment, or you pay and wait for reimbursement, depending on the contract
Sold byDealers for that brand, and prices can differ between dealersDealers of any brand, direct sellers, some lenders and insurers
Main thing to checkCoverage level and termThe company's track record and financial backing, and the exclusions

Neither type is automatically better. A manufacturer plan is usually simpler to use. A third-party plan may be the only option for an older car or a brand you are buying from a different brand's dealer. With a third-party plan, check the administrator's complaint record with your state attorney general or insurance regulator. The FTC warns that some sellers may not be in business when you need to use the contract.

How to read the contract

Ask for the contract itself, not the brochure. Brochures describe what is covered; contracts describe what is not.

Coverage type

  • Exclusionary contracts cover everything except a list of excluded parts. These are the broadest.
  • Stated-component or "named-component" contracts cover only the parts listed. If it is not on the list, it is not covered.
  • Powertrain contracts cover the engine, transmission and drive components only.

Questions to ask

Based largely on the FTC's guidance:

  • When does coverage start and end? From today, or from the car's original in-service date and zero miles? A "7-year/100,000-mile" plan measured from the original sale date is shorter than it sounds on a three-year-old car.
  • What is excluded? The FTC notes that service contracts typically do not cover accident damage or normal wear and tear. Look for exclusions for seals and gaskets, electronics, software, hybrid or EV batteries, and "pre-existing conditions".
  • What is the deductible? Per visit or per repair?
  • Where can I get repairs? Any licensed shop, a network, or only the selling dealer? What if you move or break down far from home?
  • Who pays the shop? Directly, or do you pay and get reimbursed? How long does that take?
  • Do repairs need approval first? What happens with an emergency repair at night or on a weekend?
  • Are there limits on labor rates, diagnostic time, or parts? Does it pay for teardown if the cause turns out not to be covered?
  • What maintenance must I prove? The FTC notes a contract may require you to follow all the manufacturer's maintenance recommendations, and that failing to do so might void it. Keep every receipt.
  • Does it include towing and a rental car? With what limits?
  • Can it be transferred when I sell? Is there a fee?
  • How do I cancel and what is the refund? See below.

Price

Service contract prices are not fixed. The FTC says they can range from several hundred to several thousand dollars. The dealer adds a margin, and that margin is negotiable.

  • Get quotes for the same manufacturer-backed plan from more than one dealer for the brand. Many will sell a plan for a car you bought elsewhere.
  • Compare identical terms: same coverage level, years, miles and deductible.
  • Ask for the cash price. If you roll the contract into your loan, you pay interest on it too. A $2,400 contract financed over 72 months adds about $33 a month before interest, which is how it is usually presented. Look at the total.
  • Check that it was not added without your agreement. The FTC says it is not okay for dealers to tuck add-ons into your deal. Read the itemized contract before signing; finance office: what to expect and how to read a buyer's order show where add-ons appear.

Is it worth it for you?

There is no universal answer, but a few questions sort most cases.

A contract makes more sense whenIt makes less sense when
You will keep the car well past the factory warrantyYou will sell or trade before the factory warranty ends
A large unexpected repair bill would be a real hardshipYou could cover a major repair from savings
The model is complex or has a mixed reliability recordThe model has a strong record and long factory coverage
The contract is exclusionary and backed by the manufacturerThe contract is a short list of components from a company you cannot vet
The price is modest relative to the cost of likely repairsThe price approaches what the covered repairs would cost

One alternative is to put the price of the contract into a savings account for repairs. If nothing breaks, you keep the money.

For a used car, compare a service contract with buying a certified pre-owned car, where manufacturer-backed coverage is built into the price.

Cancelling and refunds

The CFPB says that if you added an optional product such as an extended warranty to your loan, you have the right to cancel it during the term of the loan. How much you get back depends on the contract and on state law, so read the cancellation section before you buy. Common patterns:

  • A full refund if you cancel within an initial period, often stated in days, provided no claim has been made.
  • After that, a prorated refund based on time or miles used, sometimes less a cancellation fee.
  • If the contract was financed, the refund usually goes to the lender and reduces your loan balance. Your monthly payment may stay the same while the loan ends sooner.

To cancel, write to the dealer or administrator named in the contract, include the contract number and current odometer reading, keep a copy, and follow up until you have written confirmation of the refund amount. If you sell or trade the car, or pay off the loan early, cancel any remaining contract and ask for the refund you are owed.

Scam calls and mailers

Calls, texts and letters warning that your "factory warranty is about to expire" are almost never from your dealer or manufacturer. The FTC warns that such companies may pressure you for payment details right away. Do not buy a service contract from an unsolicited contact. If you want one, start with the contract terms and a company you chose.

If a claim is denied

Ask for the denial in writing with the contract section it relies on, send your maintenance records, and escalate to the administrator and the selling dealer. If that fails, contact your state attorney general or insurance regulator, or report the company at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

For the other products offered alongside service contracts, see dealer add-ons: which are worth it.

Read next · Step 4: Sign

The Dealership Finance Office: What to Expect and What Is Optional

6 min