Skip to content
The Motor Standard

Step 2 of 5 · Shop · 6 min read

Car Insurance Before You Buy: Get Quotes by VIN First

How to get insurance quotes on a specific car before you commit, what coverage lenders and leases require, how GAP works, and why the model matters.

Listen to this guide9 min

The short version

  • Quote the exact car, by VIN, before you agree to buy it. Premiums can differ between models that look alike.
  • Give every insurer the same coverages, limits and deductibles so the quotes are comparable.
  • Lenders and leasing companies usually require collision and comprehensive coverage and may set deductible or liability requirements.
  • GAP covers the difference between what you owe and what the car is worth if it is totaled or stolen. It is optional and sold by several sources.
  • Have coverage in force from the moment you take possession, and bring proof to the dealership.
In this guide
  1. How to get quotes that mean something
  2. Coverage basics
  3. What lenders and leasing companies require
  4. GAP: what it is and whether you need it
  5. How the car you pick changes the premium
  6. Timing: from quote to driving away

Get an insurance quote on the specific car before you agree to buy it. Insurance is a cost you pay every month you own the car, it depends on the vehicle as well as on you, and it is the one ownership cost you can know exactly in advance. It takes a phone call or a few minutes online, and it occasionally changes which car you choose.

How to get quotes that mean something

Quote by VIN

The VIN identifies the exact model, trim, engine and safety equipment. Two trims of the same car can be rated differently, so a quote by VIN is more reliable than a quote by "year, make, model".

  • Where to find it: dealer listings almost always show the VIN. Listings on /cars link to the dealer's own page. For a factory order, use the VIN once it is assigned, and until then quote a similar car on the lot.
  • No VIN yet? Quote by year, make, model and trim, and treat it as an estimate.

Keep everything else identical

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners advises giving every agent or company the same information so you can compare. Before you call, decide on:

  1. Liability limits
  2. Whether you want collision and comprehensive, and the deductible for each
  3. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage
  4. Extras such as rental reimbursement and roadside assistance
  5. Who in the household will drive the car, and roughly how many miles a year

Then ask each insurer for the six-month or annual premium for that exact package on each car you are considering. Three quotes is a reasonable minimum: your current insurer, one direct insurer and one independent agent who can check several companies.

A script

I am deciding between two cars and would like quotes on both before I buy. Here are the VINs. Please quote each with [liability limits], collision and comprehensive with a $[amount] deductible, and uninsured motorist coverage matching my liability limits. I will be financing, so please include anything a lender would typically require. What would each cost for six months, and what discounts are included?

Quotes do not commit you to anything.

Coverage basics

Summarized from the NAIC's consumer guide. Requirements differ by state.

CoverageWhat it pays forRequired?
Bodily injury liabilityInjuries to others when you are at faultRequired in most states
Property damage liabilityDamage you cause to other people's propertyRequired in most states
Uninsured/underinsured motoristYour losses when the at-fault driver has no or too little insuranceVaries by state
Personal injury protection or medical paymentsMedical costs for you and your passengersRequired in some states, optional in others
CollisionDamage to your car from hitting another car or objectNot by law; usually by lenders and lessors
ComprehensiveTheft, fire, weather, vandalism, flood, glassNot by law; usually by lenders and lessors

The NAIC notes that most states require some kind of insurance coverage to drive legally, and each state sets its own minimums. State minimum liability limits are a legal floor, not a recommendation. They can be far below the cost of a serious accident, and you are personally responsible for the rest. Your state insurance department publishes the minimums and consumer guides. "Full coverage" is not an official term; people usually mean liability plus collision and comprehensive.

Deductibles are what you pay per claim before the insurer pays. A higher deductible lowers the premium. Choose one you could pay tomorrow without borrowing.

What lenders and leasing companies require

If you finance or lease, the car is the lender's collateral, and the contract will say what insurance you must carry. Read the insurance section of the loan or lease agreement for:

  • Collision and comprehensive. The NAIC notes collision may be required by your lender or lessor.
  • Maximum deductibles. Some contracts cap them.
  • Liability limits. Leases often require higher limits than the state minimum. The FTC notes that with a lease you must maintain insurance that meets the leasing company's standards.
  • Loss payee. The lender is listed on your policy so that claim payments for the car protect its interest.

Ask the lender or dealer for these requirements before you get quotes, so you quote the right package.

If your coverage lapses, the CFPB explains that the lender may buy insurance for the vehicle and charge you for it. This is called force-placed insurance, and the CFPB notes it "protects the lender and vehicle, but not you". It is generally expensive. Keeping your own policy active is always the better course.

GAP: what it is and whether you need it

If your car is totaled or stolen, your insurer pays what the car is worth at that moment, not what you owe. If you owe more than it is worth, you still owe the lender the difference. The CFPB describes GAP as an optional product intended to cover that difference.

You are more likely to have a gap if:

  • you made a small down payment or none
  • your loan is long, so the balance falls slowly
  • you rolled negative equity from a previous car into the loan
  • the model loses value quickly; see depreciation explained
  • you are leasing (though many leases already include gap coverage; check the lease)

If you put a substantial amount down and chose a shorter loan, you may never owe more than the car is worth, and GAP would cover nothing.

Where to buy it

The CFPB says prices vary widely, that your own auto insurer may offer a GAP policy, and that some direct lenders do too. Dealers offer it in the finance office, usually as a single price rolled into the loan, which means you pay interest on it. Before you go to the dealership:

  1. Ask your insurer what it charges to add gap or "loan/lease payoff" coverage, and what the limits are.
  2. Ask your bank or credit union what it charges.
  3. Compare those with the dealer's price and terms.

The CFPB also states that you can cancel optional add-on products and may be entitled to a refund if you sell, refinance or pay off the loan early. Once your loan balance drops below the car's value, the coverage has done its job. Finance office: what to expect covers how GAP is presented at signing.

How the car you pick changes the premium

Insurers price each model on its claims history. The NAIC lists make and model among the rating factors, noting that luxury and sports cars average more claims. Things about a vehicle that tend to matter:

  • how often that model is in claims and how severe they are
  • what it costs to repair, including parts prices and sensors or cameras in bumpers and windshields
  • how often it is stolen
  • how well it protects occupants, and how much damage it does to others
  • its value, which sets the cost of replacing it

You do not have to guess. The Highway Loss Data Institute, affiliated with IIHS, publishes insurance loss results by make and model across six coverage types, shown as how far each model sits above or below the average for all passenger vehicles. It is a useful way to compare candidates, with one caveat from IIHS: results for a redesigned model may not match earlier versions. Your own quote is still the final word, because it combines the car with your driving record, location, age and mileage.

Add the real numbers to your total cost of ownership and your monthly budget in how much car can you afford.

Timing: from quote to driving away

  1. While shopping: quote each finalist by VIN.
  2. Before signing: pick the insurer, confirm the lender's requirements, and ask the insurer how to start coverage on the purchase date.
  3. On the day: call or use the app to add the car effective immediately, and get proof of insurance by email. The dealer will ask for it.
  4. If replacing a car: ask your insurer how long your existing policy automatically covers a newly acquired vehicle. Many policies include a grace period, but the length and the coverage that carries over vary by policy and state, so confirm it and do not rely on it.

If you are buying far from home, sort this out before you travel. Buying a car out of state covers the other steps.

Read next · Step 2: Shop

How to Read a Dealer Listing: Fine Print, VINs, and Price History

6 min